Ask for an Old Fashioned anywhere else in the country and the bartender reaches for whiskey. Ask in a Wisconsin supper club and the bottle that comes down is brandy, usually without a word, because that is what most people here mean. The drink arrives with a relish tray, or at least it used to: a plate of cold, crunchy things to pick at while you wait for your name to be called. Both habits are old, both are local, and both are worth understanding before your first Saturday night out.
A brandy state
Wisconsin drinks far more brandy than its size would suggest. For decades it has been one of the largest brandy markets in the country, and a single California brandy maker has sold a large share of its output here. Brandy turns up in places it rarely appears elsewhere: in the Old Fashioned, in a brandy Manhattan, in the frozen brandy slush that fills freezers before summer parties, and in the hot Tom and Jerry that appears in taverns around Christmas.

It is a working drink, not a luxury one. The brandy in a Wisconsin Old Fashioned is usually an inexpensive, mellow American brandy, not an aged French cognac. It is meant to be mixed.
The 1893 story
Ask how this happened and you will usually hear the same story. In 1893 Chicago hosted the World's Columbian Exposition, the great world's fair on the lakefront. Among the exhibitors, the story goes, were California brandy makers. German immigrants from Milwaukee and the rest of Wisconsin, who came down to the fair by the trainload, tasted the brandy, liked it, and carried the taste home. Distributors followed, and brandy became the state's drink.
It is a good story, and it is told in bars, books and articles across the state. Treat it as a popular story rather than settled fact. A single fair visit is unlikely to explain a habit that has lasted well over a century. Other pieces of the picture probably matter as much: the German and Central European taste for fruit brandies, the way distributors pushed particular brands in particular markets, the years after Prohibition when Wisconsin drinkers were rebuilding their habits, and above all the supper club, where brandy cocktails became a fixed part of the evening.
Whatever the cause, the result is clear. By the middle of the twentieth century, brandy was what a Wisconsin bartender poured into an Old Fashioned unless you said otherwise.
The brandy Old Fashioned
The Wisconsin version is sweeter and fruitier than the classic whiskey Old Fashioned, and it has its own vocabulary. The general method:
- Put a sugar cube or a spoonful of sugar in a rocks glass with a few dashes of aromatic bitters, an orange slice and a maraschino cherry.
- Muddle them together gently until the sugar dissolves and the orange gives up its juice.
- Fill the glass with ice and add a measure of brandy.
- Top with soda. This is where you choose: sweet means lemon-lime soda, sour means grapefruit soda or sour mix, and press means half lemon-lime soda and half soda water.
- Garnish with another orange slice and cherry, or with pickled vegetables on a pick.
Order it by saying "brandy Old Fashioned sweet," and the bartender will know what you mean. Our page on the Old Fashioned goes into the variations and the arguments about them.
The relish tray
In the classic supper club, dinner was never rushed. You arrived, ordered a drink in the bar, and waited for a table. When you sat down, a relish tray was already on the table or arrived soon after, along with a basket of bread, crackers or breadsticks.
The contents vary, but a typical tray holds:
- Carrot and celery sticks, and radishes, kept cold on ice in some places.
- Dill or sweet pickles, sometimes both.
- Green and black olives.
- Pickled beets or pickled vegetables.
- A cheese spread, often a sharp port wine or cheddar spread, with crackers.
- In some places, cottage cheese, a bean salad, or pickled herring.
The tray had a practical job. It gave diners something to eat with a second drink while the kitchen worked, and it was cheap to put together from the cooler. It also said something about the place: generosity, an evening that was meant to last, and food from the farm country around it.

Some supper clubs served the tray on a revolving lazy Susan in the center of the table, with small dishes for each item. Others brought a long, narrow glass plate. A few still do it exactly the old way.
Brandy through the year
The Old Fashioned is only the start. Wisconsin brandy follows the seasons.
In summer, many households keep a batch of brandy slush in the freezer: brandy mixed with brewed tea, frozen lemonade and orange juice concentrate, sugar and water, frozen in a pail until it turns to a soft, scoopable ice. You scoop it into a glass and top it with lemon-lime soda or soda water. It is a party drink for decks and cabins, made in quantity and rarely measured carefully.
At the end of a supper club meal, brandy often comes back in an ice cream drink. A brandy Alexander blends brandy with crème de cacao and vanilla ice cream; a grasshopper uses crème de menthe and crème de cacao instead. They are served in stemmed glasses, thick enough to need a straw, and they take the place of dessert.
In winter, taverns bring out the Tom and Jerry: a warm batter of beaten eggs and sugar spooned into a mug, topped with brandy, rum or both and hot water or milk, and dusted with nutmeg. Many families have a set of Tom and Jerry mugs that comes out of the cupboard only in December, and some bars and grocery stores sell the batter for the season.
How the tradition holds up
The relish tray has become rarer. Food costs and changing tastes have pushed many restaurants to drop it or to charge for it. Where it survives, it is often one of the reasons regulars keep coming back, and some newer supper clubs have revived it on purpose. Brandy has held up better. The brandy Old Fashioned is still the default order in taverns, supper clubs and Friday fish fry dining rooms across the state, and it has gained new followers who seek out the old supper clubs because of it.
Around the Kettle Moraine, the habits are alive in the older supper clubs along the lake roads and county highways, where the dining room has a view of the water and the bar has a long padded rail.

How to find it today
Go on a Friday or Saturday evening, when supper clubs are at their busiest and most traditional. Arrive early, put your name in, and order a brandy Old Fashioned sweet at the bar while you wait. Ask the bartender whether the house brings a relish tray; if it does, you will see it on the tables as you walk through to your seat.
Eat the relish tray slowly. Spread the cheese on a cracker, take a radish, have a pickle. Order the fish on Friday or prime rib on Saturday, finish with an ice cream drink such as a grasshopper or a brandy Alexander, and take your time. Nobody at a supper club is in a hurry, and you should not be either.
