Coyote CanyonField notes · Kettle Moraine, Wisconsin

The Friday Table · Field note

The Wisconsin brandy old fashioned: the method, the toppers and the garnishes

Muddle the fruit gently, use brandy rather than whiskey, then decide whether you want it sweet, sour or press before you top the glass.

The Wisconsin brandy old fashioned: the method, the toppers and the garnishes

Ask for an old fashioned anywhere in Wisconsin and the bartender may well reach for brandy before you say a word. Elsewhere the drink is whiskey, sugar and bitters, stirred and served strong. Here it is something sweeter and longer: brandy over muddled fruit, topped with soda. It is the drink of the supper club bar and the Friday fish fry, and it is easy to make at home once you know the order of things.

Why brandy

Wisconsin's taste for brandy is old. The story most often told points to German immigrants, who had a long fondness for fruit brandies, and to the steady supply of California brandy that reached the Midwest through the twentieth century. However it began, by the years after the Second World War the brandy old fashioned was the standard order at Wisconsin bars, and the state still drinks a large share of the country's brandy.

The muddled fruit and the soda topper mark it as a Midwestern drink. The older whiskey cocktail it descends from had neither.

An old fashioned glass with an orange twist beside a Manhattan
An old fashioned glass with an orange twist beside a Manhattan

The method

You need a short rocks glass, a muddler or the handle of a wooden spoon, and ice. Measures are a guide; adjust to taste.

  1. Sugar and bitters. Put a sugar cube, or about a teaspoon of sugar or simple syrup, in the bottom of the glass. Shake in two or three dashes of aromatic bitters.
  2. Fruit. Add a slice of orange, peel on, and one or two maraschino cherries. Some bartenders add a splash of the cherry juice.
  3. Muddle. Press the fruit and sugar together until the orange gives up its juice and the sugar is mostly dissolved. Press, do not pulverise. Shredded peel turns the drink bitter.
  4. Ice and brandy. Fill the glass with ice and pour in about one and a half to two ounces of brandy.
  5. Top it. Fill the glass with your chosen topper, then stir once or twice to bring the fruit up.
  6. Garnish. Finish with a fresh orange slice and a cherry, or with the savoury garnishes that go with a sour.

Sweet, sour or press

The topper is the decision that defines the drink, and every Wisconsin bartender will ask.

  • Sweet uses a lemon-lime soda. It is the most common order and the easiest to drink, which is a reason to go carefully with it.
  • Sour uses a grapefruit soda or, at some bars, a splash of sour mix. It is sharper and less sugary.
  • Press is half lemon-lime soda and half soda water, a middle way that lets the brandy and bitters come through.

A sour old fashioned is often garnished with something pickled on a pick: button mushrooms, green olives, a pickled Brussels sprout or a small pickled onion. It sounds strange and works well; the brine plays against the sweetness. A sweet stays with orange and cherry.

A short old fashioned glass on a bar beside a cocktail glass
A short old fashioned glass on a bar beside a cocktail glass

Choosing the ingredients

The drink is simple, so each part shows.

  • Brandy. Most Wisconsin bars pour an inexpensive American brandy, and that is the right choice. Its soft, fruity sweetness suits the soda. An expensive aged cognac is wasted under lemon-lime.
  • Cherries. Bright red maraschino cherries are traditional. Darker cocktail cherries in syrup are richer and less sweet; either works, but the red ones are what a supper club uses.
  • Oranges. Use a thick round or half-round of navel orange with the peel on. The oil in the peel is half the flavour.
  • Soda. Open a fresh bottle or can. Flat soda makes a flat drink, and the topper is a third of the glass.
  • Ice. Fill the glass. Too little ice melts fast and waters the drink down.

Making them for a crowd at home, set out the glasses in a row, put sugar, bitters and fruit in each, and muddle them all before any ice goes in. Then add ice, brandy and topper glass by glass as people decide sweet, sour or press. Keep the soda cold and the bottles capped between rounds.

Variations you will meet

  • Whiskey old fashioned. Same method, with bourbon or rye in place of brandy. Ask for it by name.
  • Muddled versus not. Some bars build the drink without muddling, simply adding fruit to the glass. Muddling makes a fuller, fruitier drink.
  • Bitters. A few bartenders add an extra dash of orange or cherry bitters. The standard is plain aromatic bitters.
  • No liquor. Build the drink exactly as above, leave out the brandy and top with half lemon-lime soda and half soda water. It is a good drink in its own right for drivers and anyone not drinking.

When to drink one

The old fashioned belongs to the hour before supper: at the bar of a supper club while you wait for a table, or alongside the plate at a Friday fish fry. It goes naturally with the crackers and cheese spread on a relish tray, a pairing explained under brandy and the relish tray.

Treat it with respect. A well-made old fashioned hides its strength under the fruit and soda, and the second one goes down faster than the first. One before supper is the custom; arrange your ride before you order.

At home, make them one at a time, in the glass you will drink from, and stir with the muddler still in your hand.